Surrender At Saratoga - "The Greatest Conquest Ever Known"

For some time I assumed Lieutenant-General John Burgoyne's Saratoga Campaign came to an end in mid-October of 1777, when his army had advanced south as far as it was able, only to be stopped in its tracks and forced to surrender.  When I started exploring the route of the Convention Army, I assumed that the Surrender Site would be where British and German troops had laid down their arms.  Now, after some additional research, and a weekend visit to Saratoga National Historical Park, I've learned those assumptions were wrong - and another visit to Schuylerville is in order, as there is more to see there than I'd realized.

The story of Burgoyne's surrender at Saratoga is linked to a a number of locations.  One would be what is now called "Victory Woods", a misleading name from the British perspective perhaps, that reflects its location in the present-day Village of Victory, incorporated in 1849, rather than any description of the site in 1777.  It was there, after a night move north away from Bemis Heights on October 9th, that Burgoyne gathered his forces in what became their final defensive position.  

For four days the opposing armies exchanged cannon fire and musket shot as American Major-General Horatio Gates' position grew stronger, and Burgoyne's weaker through casualties and desertions.  On the 14th, American Light Infantry forces commander Major Henry Dearborn noted "at 10 O Clock to Day a flag Came from Genr'l Burgoyn with some Proposals of Caputilation in Consiquence of which a sessation of armes was agreed on until sun set in which Time several flags Pass.d Between Genr'l Gates and Burgoyne." [1]  

For two more days the ceasefire continued, as Burgoyne worked out an agreement with Gates.  Blocked by militia units on the east bank of the Hudson River and pressured by Major-General Horatio Gates' Continental Army brigades, Burgoyne realized it was unlikely he would be able to retreat north to Fort Ticonderoga, and agreed to the terms of the Articles of Convention.  Included was that on the 17th the formal signing of the Convention would occur at 9:00, and Burgoyne's troops would march out of their ""Victory Woods" camp "to the verge of the river where the old fort stood, where the arms and artillery are to be left..." [2]

A reproduction cannon placed at the Saratoga Surrender Site monument faces east across the Hudson River.
My visit to Saratoga included a stop at the Surrender Site, which offers a view of the Hudson River Valley, and to the southeast, the first of the mountain ranges the Convention Army would need to cross.  Today several stone monuments and two reproduction British cannons mark the site where signage indicates that it was here that Burgoyne offered his sword in surrender to Gates.  

That moment is captured in bronze on the central plaque in a cast version of John Trumbull's painting the Surrender of General Burgoyne, flanked by quotes from four of those present in 1777: Gates, Massachusetts Militia Private Ezra Tilton, British Lieutenant William Digby, and Lady Frederica Riedesel, wife of the German forces commander.

Many present on the 17th recorded their observations.  Dearborn noted "this Day the Great Mr. Burgoyn with his whole Army Surrendered themselves as Prisoners of war with all their Publick Stores, & after Grounding their armes march.d of[f] for New England, the greatest Conquest Ever known." [3]  Colonel Jeduthan Baldwin, one of Gates's engineers, noted "About 11 o clock A.M. the enemy laid down there arms & Marched out thro our Army the most agreeable sight that my eyes beheld."  [4]

Perhaps most remarkable is an observation that captured a particular point of protocol (emphasis added, but original spellings retained) by Elisha James, who noted "... Generall Burgoyne & his generall officers Rid to meet him [Gates,] Burgoyne came up to Generall Gates with his hatt Off and Shook hands & then took the Left hand of Generral Gates & Rid aboute a half mile to Generall Gates head Quarters follow'd by Gener'll Glovers Brigades with the fifes and Drums which Play'd the yankee Dudle ... the Generall viewed our Army as they Rode along  I trust with Some Surprise to See them Behave So well there was no laughing nor pointing..." Burgoyne, fully conversant in military protocol, recognized that in having surrendered his place as they rode off was on the left, despite his outranking Gates - in other words, though unspoken, the position of one subordinate. [5] 

Less well known, to me at least, was "where the old fort stood", the site of Fort Hardy in the Village of Schuylerville.  It was here that British and German troops laid down their arms.  British Lieutenant William Digby of the 53rd Regiment of Foot noted of the British, who marched out before the Germans "About 10 o'clock, we marched out... though we beat the Grenadiers march, which not long before was so animating, yet then it seemed by its last feeble effort, as if almost ashamed to be heard on such an occasion.  As to my own feelings, I can not express them.  Tears (though most unmanly) forced their way, and if alone, I could have burst to give myself vent."  Major-General Friedrick Riedesel, commander of the German forces, recalled in his Memoirs "At eleven o'clock, the army left their old fortified camp, and formed in line on the ground near the so called old fort, - this [north] side of the Fishkill.  Here they left their cannon and muskets..." [6]

View of Major-General Philip Schuyler's country home in Saratoga New York as rebuilt after being burned in October of 1777
My travel partner and I found Schuylerville to be a pleasant town, though we we didn't take sufficient time to explore it.  

While we failed to visit the site of Fort Hardy, we did stop to walk on the grounds of Major-General Philip Schuyler's Country Estate, seen as it was rebuilt in November of 1777, after Burgoyne ordered it burned on October 10, 1777. The house is part of the National Historical Park, and said to be open seasonally for tours.  We're looking forward to going back and seeing more, including inside the Schuyler House, Victory Woods and the Saratoga Monument (though it is closed for repairs as I write this).

Unlike Burgoyne's troops, our overnight stay was a pleasure, spent in comfort in nearby Saratoga Springs.  Should you go, we'd recommend staying in one of the hotels on or near Broadway.  We enjoyed walking from our hotel to dinner with a Spanish flair at Boca Bistro, exploring interesting shops and Congress Park along the way, and the next morning starting our day with coffee and pastry at Uncommon Grounds. (As an aside, none of the sites mentioned is a paid advertisement or promotion, just somewhere we enjoyed, and we saw plenty of other places that we look forward to trying in the future.)

[1] Dearborn, Major Henry, Journal, p. 9.
[2] Articles of Convention, Articles I and XIII.
[3] Dearborn, p. 10.
[4] The Revolutionary Journal of Col. Jeduthan Balwin, p. 125.
[5] McKenzie, Matthew, Barefooted, Bar Leg'd Bare Breeched, p. 62.
[6] Digby, Journal, pp. 319-320; Riedesel, Memoirs, p. 188.

Next week: Burgoyne - "Mutual and Peculiar Sufferers"

For more on the Convention Army's 1777 march from Saratoga to Boston, see:

1777 March Blog Home          Overnight Stopping Points          Towns and Villages Along the Way

 Annotated Bibliography



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

George Washington and Saratoga - "A Matter Of Such Magnitude"

The Battle Of Hubbardton - "No Visible Advantage"

Burgoyne’s Camp Kettle - “Captured October 17, 1777, In The Battle Of Saratoga[?]”