Burgoyne Surrenders - "The Generals In America Doing Nothing, Or Worse Than Nothing"

By

Thursday, October 17, 2024, is the 247th anniversary of British Lieutenant-General John Burgoyne's surrender at Saratoga, New York.  The final days of his failed campaign are being remembered during "Siege Weekend" on October 12th and 13th at Saratoga National Historical Park, and a variety of other locations listed on the Saratoga 250 Events Page.  A month-long program of events, beginning with the Battle of Freeman's Farm, culminates on the 17th in a community remembrance of the surrender at 10:00 AM at Fort Hardy Park in Schuylerville, New York, Saratoga National Historical Park rangers at the site where Burgoyne surrendered about a mile south of Fort Hardy on Route 4, and at 6:00 PM, a "Surrender Day Benefit" in Saratoga Springs.  For those who like to plan ahead, 2025's commemoration of "Victory Season at Saratoga" is already on the Saratoga 250 website.

Looking back, one of the earliest images of Burgoyne's surrender appears to have been published in London in June of 1779.  The scene is one of a dozen in an engraving entitled "The political raree-show: or a picture of parties and politics, during and at the close of the last session of Parliament, June 1779" in the collection of of the Boston Public Library, accessed on the Digital Commonwealth website.  

In the surrender panel, British soldiers kneel to lay down their arms and colors as a victorious American army looks on.  In the foreground a British general, presumably Burgoyne, sits outside his tent with two wine bottles under his chair, and one leg up on a table which holds a punch bowl and playing cards.  The caption to the panel, "The Generals In America Doing Nothing, Or Worse Than Nothing", reflects the frustration felt by many in Great Britain over the lack of progress made to bring the rebellion in the North American colonies to an end.

The 2024 Surrender Day ceremony at Fort Hardy likely will include the event shown in a painting by John Trumbull, which captures the moment that Burgoyne offered his sword to American Major-General Horatio Gates.  Trumbull's painting, entitled "Surrender of General Burgoyne", was completed in 1821 based on sketches of the site he did in 1791, and portraits he painted in the 1790's.  This image, like others he did of Bunker Hill, Trenton and Yorktown, celebrates American victories during the Revolutionary War. 

There are some problems with both images - and the surrender commemoration.  Despite what the 1779 engraving shows, Burgoyne's army surrendered out of sight of the American army.  His British troops stacked their arms, rather than kneeling to ground them, and there has been some disagreement over what happened to the flags said to have been carried by the various British and German regiments which surrendered on October 17th.  With regard to Trumbull's painting, it's questionable whether the American flag was flown over Gates' headquarters at Saratoga, and if so, if this was the first time that it was flown as some have claimed.  

The Fort Hardy ceremony on the 17th will commemorate the surrender of arms which occurred there in 1777, as well as Burgoyne's surrender to Gates, despite that actually occurring down the road a ways at Gates headquarters.  The Fort Hardy ceremony likely won't include reenactors portraying each of the American officers Trumbull shows looking on, including Major-General Philip Schuyler standing behind the wheels of the cannon, clad in civilian cloths rather than a uniform, and to his right brigadier-generals John Glover and William Whipple, who would escort Burgoyne from Albany to Cambridge.  Instead, the 2024 onlookers will include the general public and local schoolchildren.

Regardless, none of these questions or details should cast a shadow on the 2024 celebration which recognizes the accomplishment of the Northern Army at Saratoga, where a combined force of Continental troops and militia defeated a British army, and in doing so changed the course of history.



For more on the Convention Army's 1777 march from Saratoga to Boston, see:
   General Whipple's Journal         Burgoyne in Albany                    Annotated Bibliography  
 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

George Washington and Saratoga - "A Matter Of Such Magnitude"

By
Image
February 22, 2023, marks the 291st anniversary of the birth of George Washington, pictured here in a  Library of Congress  print published in Germany in 1777 or 1778.  For more than two centuries Washington's birth has been widely noted, and was a federally recognized holiday from 1885 to 1971.  For the last five decades an all encompassing "Presidents' Day" has supplanted not only a holiday observance on the date of Washington's birth, but the February 12th celebration of the birthday of another truly great American President, Abraham Lincoln. In the fall of 1777 Washington hands were full as commander-in-chief of the Continental Army.  While Major-General Horatio Gates defended the upper Hudson River Valley, Washington was responding to British General Sir William Howe's expedition moving not north to support Burgoyne, but south by ship into the Chesapeake Bay and then north by land to Philadelphia.  On September 11th British forces maneuvered to flank Washi
Read more

The Battle Of Hubbardton - "No Visible Advantage"

By
Image
On July 6, 1777, British and German forces under the command of Lieutenant-General John Burgoyne occupied the American fortifications at Fort Ticonderoga and Mount Independence  and took control of Lake Champlain.  Outnumbered, American troops retired south to Skenesboro, some by boat, others by land southeast on military roads to Castleton, Vermont.  Burgoyne responded by focusing his attention on those fleeing by boat, and left the pursuit of those who traveled by land to the commander of his Advance Corps, Brigadier-General Simon Fraser, "Knowing how safely I could trust to that officers conduct."   [1] British Lieutenant James Hadden of the Royal Artillery noted in his Journal :  "July 6th At daybreak this Morning the retreat of the Enemy was discover'd, and B. Gen'l Frazer, with about 8 or 900 of his own Corps (leaving the rest with the Tents Batteaux's &c &c) pursued them towards Huberton, leaving his Artillery which the Road was not capable o
Read more

Burgoyne's Artillery - "Drawn Through The Village"

By
Image
Lieutenant-General John Burgoyne's British and German troops marched out of their camp and entrenchments at Saratoga on the morning of October 17, 1777, and left their arms and artillery at  "the verge of the river where the old fort stood."  [1]   Supposedly, "With a moist eye the artilleryman looked for the last time upon his faithful gun parting with it as he would from a bride - and that, forever!"  [2]  For the American army, the surrendered artillery was something to be secured, inventoried, and redistributed for use in future battles against their former owners.   A German office would note:  "England's greatest loss may be considered the loss of the  artillery, which was taken by the rebels."  - though Britain's loss of an army, the boost to American morale, and the resulting alliance between the United States and France was surely more significant. [3]   An account of  the Convention Army's stop in Great Barrington includes a stor
Read more